5 Sacagawea Coins That Turned Spare Change Into Six-Figure Payouts

For most people in the U.S., Sacagawea dollar coins—first released in the year 2000—don’t seem very special. They often end up forgotten at the bottom of change jars or tucked into coin collections without much attention.

But hidden among these shiny golden coins are a few that are truly rare and worth much more than just one dollar. In fact, some of these coins have sold for huge amounts—sometimes over $100,000—at auctions and through private collectors. Below are five amazing Sacagawea dollars that shocked the coin world and brought big money to lucky owners.

2000-P Sacagawea Dollar with Washington Quarter Front — Sold for $155,250

This is one of the most well-known modern coin mistakes. It’s called a “mule” coin because it was made using the front of a Washington state quarter and the back of a Sacagawea dollar.

This strange mix-up happened at the Philadelphia Mint by accident. It’s something that’s not supposed to happen during coin production, which made collectors very excited.

Only about 20 of these error coins are known to exist. In 2018, one of them sold for a jaw-dropping $155,250. Collectors love them not only because they’re rare, but also because of how unusual they look. The fact that this kind of error made it past quality control makes it even more valuable and interesting.

2000-P “Cheerios” Sacagawea Dollar — Worth $25,000 to Over $100,000

Back in 2000, General Mills worked with the U.S. Mint to include 5,500 special Sacagawea dollars inside boxes of Cheerios cereal. This was done to help promote the new dollar coin.

At the time, people thought these were just normal coins—until a few years later when collectors noticed something different about them.

These Cheerios coins had a special eagle tail feather design on the back that wasn’t used in the regular coins. This version is called the “pattern reverse” or “Cheerios reverse.” Because of this difference, they are now considered prototypes and are very rare. Coins in great condition have been sold for as much as $100,000, making them one of the most wanted modern U.S. coins.

2000-P Sacagawea Dollar Made on a Quarter Blank — Sold for $79,312.50

Sometimes, mistakes happen during the coin-making process when the wrong blank, also called a planchet, is used. This is exactly what happened here. Instead of using the correct blank for a dollar coin, a smaller blank meant for a quarter was used to make this Sacagawea dollar.

As a result, the coin was smaller than normal and missing some of the design details. Despite this obvious error, it still made it out of the Mint and into the hands of collectors. At a coin auction, this rare piece sold for a total of $79,312.50. Its value came from both the mistake and its excellent condition.

2000-D Sacagawea Dollar with Special Rinse — Valued Up to $50,000

Unlike most error coins that are created from wrong blanks or stamping problems, this one stands out because of how it was chemically treated. These 2000-D Sacagawea coins were dipped in a test rinse meant to make them look better and last longer.

This rinse gave the coin a shinier and darker appearance. The U.S. Mint never shared exactly how many of these experimental coins were made, but a small number have been confirmed by coin experts. Depending on the coin’s grade and condition, they can be worth between $10,000 and $50,000 or even more to collectors.

2000-P Sacagawea Dollar with Off-Center Strike — Sold for $66,000

Another popular kind of error is the off-center strike, which happens when the coin design is not lined up properly. One 2000-P Sacagawea dollar had a striking error that placed the design 30% off from where it should be. This made the coin look very unusual and instantly caught the eyes of error collectors.

Because it was in near-perfect condition and had such a dramatic misprint, the coin ended up selling for a remarkable $66,000. Its high price came from how rare this type of mistake is, along with the coin’s eye-catching look and strong collector demand.

Final Thoughts

Most Sacagawea dollar coins are still only worth one dollar—but some rare versions could change your life. From minting errors to test versions and special releases like the Cheerios coin, there are still treasures out there hiding in plain sight. These coins prove that you don’t always need to go digging for gold—sometimes, you just need to check your pocket change.

FAQs – Sacagawea Coins